Narendra Modi is right: Jawaharlal Nehru failed to appreciate foresight of General Thimayya, Field Marshal Cariappa
History is replete with facts which are uncomfortable to a family and its apologists. So whenever an uncomfortable fact comes out to the public, these people go all out to discredit the messenger. On Thursday as soon as Prime Minister Narendra Modi brought out some facts which have been hidden in the pages of history, the cabal of family apologists started attacking him. These people have been nitpicking on the General Kodandera Subayya Thimayya point that Modi made during his campaign in Karnataka. The fact is that both Nehru and VK Krishna Menon insulted General Thimayya, the latter's behaviour led to Thimayya's resignation and that can never be whitewashed. Modi was right when he spoke of General Thimayya defeating Pakistan in 1948. The fake Swarajists must know that "Timmy (Thimayya) had displayed great courage and dash amidst bursting shells in Kashmir in 1948, and he had driven the Pakistanis out of Chad Bet in Kutch in 1956, by a bold stroke even while the Cabinet was debating schemes to accomplish this."
Thus, General Thimayya did defeat Pakistani forces both in 1948 and 1956 and his confrontation with Krishna Menon happened in 1959, by when he was not only a decorated soldier with wide popularity but also the Chief of Army Staff. Modi was right thus when he said that General Thimayya had defeated Pakistan. But because Modi is a habitual kaamdar and not an naamdar Swarajist or a historian, with ample time to smoke the pipes of time-pass intellectualism, his arguments are broad and yet historically correct. Unfortunately, since Modi did not learn his history and the practice of footnoting from the exalted halls and classrooms of a war college or institution abroad like so many of us, he can be laughed off by the naamdars as muddling up, in spite of his argument and tenor being to the point and on the dot!
Veteran journalist and an astute India observer, the legendary Durga Das, for example, writes in his wide survey of modern India how Nehru himself treated General Thimayya in a cavalier fashion when he openly ticked off Thimayya, then Chief of Army Staff, "at a Governor's Conference for even suggesting the possibility of an attack by China".
In his detailed study of the Nehru years – Nehru: a Troubled Legacy the veteran scholar RNP Singh devotes an entire chapter to defence policy in post-independence India (1947-1962) and argues that "The way Nehru handled the resignation of General Thimayya dealt a bad blow to the discipline of the Armed Forces and their self-confidence."
General Thimayya resigned on 1 September 1959, "in protest against Defence Minister VK Krishna Menon's" discourteous behaviour and repeated refusal to "consider his plans for better preparation of the army". Nehru was aware that the "relations between the Defence Minister and the chief of army were strained" but he had done nothing to sort the issue out or to assuage the feelings of General Thimayya. Obviously, his obsessive admiration for and dependence on Menon had adversely influenced his capacities for independent thinking when it came to the defence establishment and its challenges. All that the prime minister did was to tell Parliament that the chief of army staff had resigned on "issues trivial and of no consequences which had arisen out of temperamental conflict".
This was Nehru’s cavalier response to the resignation of one of the greatest generals of India and one of the most illustrious sons of the soil of Karnataka. "If the prime minister was letting down and humiliating the chief of army staff, he was also ignoring the fact that the general's resignation had sprung from valid grounds which were relevant to the discipline and efficiency of the armed forces at a time when the country's frontiers were being threatened," wrote Durga Das. 1962 was not far away, and the debacle that year proved General Thimayya’s prescience.
So acerbic was Nehru when alerted that the army and its structures and appointments were being politicised that on another occasion when General Kodandera M Cariappa observed that "politics was slowly creeping into the army", Nehru retorted that "What General Cariappa calls politics is something which he does not like."
Modi has hit where it hurts the most and has reiterated the historic reality that Nehru had insulted General Thimayya. And his great-grandson, Rahul Gandhi, continues with the tirade against the armed forces, insulting their bravery by questioning the truth of the surgical strikes and supporting those subversive elements who rejoice when members of our security forces are killed in encounters by terrorists or ambushed by cowardly Naxals.
I rejoice at the fact that periodically Modi publicly reiterates crucial facets from the history of our immediate past so that the memory of the discrimination faced by some of our most illustrious patriots at the hands of a confused and arrogant political family is kept alive in the collective consciousness of our proud and great nation.
Related Topics
Related News & Articles
IRCTC live streaming: The live feed of kitchens has been hosted on the IRCTC website under the Gallery section. However, within days of launch the section shows o...
Recently posted . 573 views . 2 min read
Nirav Modi's two apartments in New York's Central Park were worth $29.99 million or Rs. 216 crores.
Recently posted . 632 views . 1 min read
The challenge for Modi is to convince the nation’s political class, still rooted in a socialist past, why disposing of Air India is in the country’s b...
Recently posted . 924 views . 6 min read
Marta Kotlarska, a Polish artist and photographer was blacklisted by the Foreigner Regional Registration Office in Uttarakhand for overstaying.
Recently posted . 526 views . 1 min read
The CBI said it had shared the information on his passport in the 'diffusion' notice issued through Interpol on February 15. But Interpol branches of Belgiu...
Recently posted . 584 views . 2 min read
Trending News & Articles
While the Uttarakhand High Court has asked to block 857 websites, the Ministry of Electronics and IT (Meity) found 30 portals without any pornographic content.
...
Recently posted . 61K views . 1 min read
The four boys as well as five school officials, including the director and principal, were arrested after the incident. The minors were presented before the Juvenil...
Recently posted . 8K views . 1 min read
Rahul was having an Italian passport and was carrying suitcase full of dollars. Some say it was about was it $2 million.
Rahul and his girl friend was th...
Recently posted . 7K views . 7 min read
True – Tr...
Recently posted . 6K views . 83 min read
More in National
From this academic session, engineering colleges the nation over should refund the charge gathered from the understudies in the event that they don't join the c...
Recently posted. 757 views . 12 min read
Sexist outbursts from our politicians are nothing new.
In yet another casual display of sexism, a 77-year-old BJP MP from Chhattisgarh, Bhansi Lal Mahato...
Recently posted. 1K views . 3 min read
As the Narendra Modi government proceeds with the grandiose plans for a bullet train between Mumbai and Ahmedabad, a RTI query has revealed that over 40% seats on a...
Recently posted. 858 views . 7 min read
Recently posted . 1K views
Recently posted . 808 views
Recently posted . 1K views
Recently posted . 1K views
Recently posted . 2K views . 94 min read
Recently posted . 1K views . 48 min read
A source said that the last time so many yaks had died was in 1994-95 after the region received heavy snowfall which wiped out the entire herd.
Recently posted. 542 views . 1 min read
The US administration hs defendant the businesses of golf shot further tickets within the lottery system - quite the visas they need - so the lion's sh...
Recently posted. 694 views . 22 min read