Latest News

    • Home
    • National
    • Why Sikhs Are Angry With the Ayodhya Judgment
    Why Sikhs Are Angry With the Ayodhya Judgment
    Friday, November 15, 2019 IST
    Why Sikhs Are Angry With the Ayodhya Judgment

    The 1045-page judgment not only refers to Sikhism as a 'cult' but also quotes accounts of Sikhs worshipping idols, which experts believe is an affront to the religious history of Sikhs.

     
     

    As it attempted to sort out a century-old Hindu-Muslim issue with its 1045-page judgment on the Ayodhya land dispute, the Supreme Court has inadvertently riled Sikhs. It has described their religion as a ‘cult’ and seems to have relied on the testimony of someone who Sikhs believe has “misinterpreted the purpose of Guru Nanak Dev’s visit to Ayodhya in 1510-1511”.
     
    The court relied on the testimony of one Rajinder Singh, ‘a person having interest in the study of religious, cultural and historical books of Sikh cult’ who had been fielded as a witness by Hindu parties to strengthen their claim to the disputed site.
     
    The apex court further noted on Rajinder Singh’s evidence, “In his examination-in-chief, he has referred to several books about Sikh cult and history.”
     
    The Kendri Guru Singh Sabha in Chandigarh has publicly criticised the judgment and described it as an “affront” to the Sikh community. “The court has called us a ‘cult’ — a word which bears a definite negative connotation. The learned judges should have consulted experts before doing so,” said professor Gurdarshan Singh Dhillon, a Sikh historian associated with the Sabha.
     
    The Cambridge English dictionary describes a cult as “a religious group, often living together, whose beliefs are considered extreme or strange by many people”. The Merriam Webster dictionary says that a cult is “a religion regarded as unorthodox or spurious.”
     
    Neena Singh, a Delhi lawyer, has written to the Supreme Court registrar that she and a group of Sikh lawyers will be submitting a representation to the Chief Justice of India soon, asking for a correction of the portion of the judgment that refers to Sikhism as a cult. “It is derogatory and goes against all that Sikhism stands for. The judges should have rebuked the witness for using such language against a peaceful and independent religion like ours. The community is shocked and hurt by the false submissions of the witness and the judgment of the Supreme Court,” Singh said.
     
    This is not all.
     
    Sikh intellectuals are also angry over the allegedly false janam sakhies or biographical writings about the Guru that have been taken on record by the apex court from the evidence presented before the Allahabad high court. These state that Guru Nanak Dev went to the alleged Ram Janambhoomi in Ayodhya for ‘darshan’.
     
    “Guru Nanak Dev went to religious places like Mecca or Ayodhya to preach and spread the message of one formless God. He did not go for ‘darshan’ at any place. There is no place for idol worship or ritualism in Sikhism and the Guru, in fact, preached against it,” said Singh.
     
    Gurpreet Singh, president of the Kendri Guru Singh Sabha said, “Instead of relying on an unknown person, the court should have asked for opinions from Sikh historians or the Akal Takht or the Shiromani Gurdwara Prabandhak Committee who would have produced authentic ‘janam sakhies’ written by renowned Sikh writers and not a ‘fictitious’ account that has been presented before it.”
     
    There is another reference in the judgment to a nihang or armed Sikh warrior, Faqir Khasa, lighting a havan fire and doing puja at the alleged Ram Janambhoomi on November 28, 1858.
     
    Quoting a report by the Thanedar of Oudh, the judgment notes, “The report spoke of an incident during which Hawan and Puja was organised inside the mosque by a Nihang Sikh who had erected a religious symbol.”
     
    This has also attracted the ire of the Sikhs who say that in Sikhism there is no custom associated with fire and puja. Nihang Sikhs are baptised Sikhs who do not engage in pujas.
     
    But more than anything else, Sikhs are uncomfortable with how the Supreme Court has seen it fit to insert the Sikh religion into what they believe is purely a Hindu-Muslim conflict. “This was entirely unnecessary. We do not wish to take sides in this issue. To distort our 550-year-old history and religion is a humiliation and only serves to diminish the faith in the eyes of the world,” said the Sabha president.
     
    The apparent “ignorance” of the Supreme Court about the basic tenets of the Sikh faith has confounded Sikh scholars and experts, some of whom have seen it as a definite affront to its glorious heritage.

     
     
     
     
     

    Related Topics

     
     
     

    Trending News & Articles

     Article
    Here is the full list of 827 porn websites banned by the DoT

    While the Uttarakhand High Court has asked to block 857 websites, the Ministry of Electronics and IT (Meity) found 30 portals without any pornographic content. ...

    Recently posted . 61K views . 1 min read
     

     Article
    Class XII Boys Raped 16-Year-old in Dehradun School After Watching Porn on Phone: Police

    The four boys as well as five school officials, including the director and principal, were arrested after the incident. The minors were presented before the Juvenil...

    Recently posted . 8K views . 1 min read
     

     Article
    Sept 27,2001 Rahul Gandhi and his girl friend Veronique,was arrested in Logan airport in Boston

    Rahul was having an Italian passport and was carrying suitcase full of dollars. Some say it was about was it $2 million. Rahul and his girl friend was th...

    Recently posted . 7K views . 7 min read
     

     Article
    TOP 10 GYM EQUIPMENT BRANDS IN INDIA 2017

    True – Tr...

    Recently posted . 6K views . 83 min read
     

     
     

    More in National

     Article
    Nine out of ten Indians favour Narendra Modi in spite of demonetisation, shows survey by think tank Pew

      The gale force disruption of demonetising 86% of India’s currency last November has not dented Narendra Modi’s popularity one bit, he ...

    Recently posted. 667 views . 2 min read
     

     Article
    Plastic ban in Maharashtra: What is allowed, what’s banned

    Maharashtra plastic ban: As per the notification, violators will be fined Rs 5,000 and Rs 10,000 for the first and second-time offense. A third-time offender will...

    Recently posted. 719 views . 1 min read
     

     Article
    10 Amazing facts about India’s first floating laboratory

    Loktak Lake is the largest freshwater lake in Northeast India and is famous for the phumdis (heterogeneous mass of vegetation, soil and organic matter at various ...

    Recently posted. 572 views . 2 min read
     

     Video
    This information is also important



    Recently posted . 702 views
     

     Photo
    Seven Must Know Natural Wonders of India



    Recently posted . 1K views
     

     Reviews
    Top 5 Bestseller Novels in India 2018



    Recently posted . 1K views . 35 min read
     

     Article
    Planning your summer vacation? Here are the top 10 hotels in India as voted by travellers

    TripAdvisor, a renowned travel portal has released a list of top ten Indian hotels to stay based on the reviews by travellers. The list is dominated by properties...

    Recently posted. 541 views . 1 min read
     

     Article
    Bullet train network to connect Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata, Chennai? Know about plans for high-speed rail

    In order to connect the four major metro cities of the country namely, Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata and Chennai, the government has identified routes for feasibility st...

    Recently posted. 574 views . 1 min read
     

     
     
     

       Prashnavali

      Thought of the Day

    “Success is one percent inspiration, ninety-nine percent perspiration.”
    Thomas Edison

    Be the first one to comment on this story

    Close
    Post Comment
    Shibu Chandran
    2 hours ago

    Serving political interests in another person's illness is the lowest form of human value. A 70+ y old lady has cancer.

    November 28, 2016 05:00 IST
    Shibu Chandran
    2 hours ago

    Serving political interests in another person's illness is the lowest form of human value. A 70+ y old lady has cancer.

    November 28, 2016 05:00 IST
    Shibu Chandran
    2 hours ago

    Serving political interests in another person's illness is the lowest form of human value. A 70+ y old lady has cancer.

    November 28, 2016 05:00 IST
    Shibu Chandran
    2 hours ago

    Serving political interests in another person's illness is the lowest form of human value. A 70+ y old lady has cancer.

    November 28, 2016 05:00 IST


    ads
    Back To Top