Do We Need God To Be Good??
Sunday, September 23, 2018 IST
Most of us feel that without God, our society would slide into chaos — people will loot with impunity, most social norms would break down and eventually, the human race would revert to a barbaric way of life — what it was, thousands of years ago. Fear of God, they ardently feel, is what holds us back from this anarchy. Besides, let us not be concerned here with individual goodness or the lack of it, but discuss the effect that belief in God has, on a collective scale, like on an entire country.
The United Nations (UN) ranks many countries on a Human Development Index (HDI) which gives weightage to indicators like civic consciousness, law and order problems, crime rates per capita, empowerment of women, child mortality, gender equality, public health, economic growth and others. HDI (its maximum score can be 1) has been accepted as a benchmark, calculated by a neutral and reliable enough authority, to define the state of well-being of a country.
There are at least three countries — Norway, Sweden and Netherlands — that consistently get a high HDI rank (among the top 15 in the world) but where more than 50 per cent of the population admit to being atheists. The goodness in these countries does not seem to have got affected by their atheism and society there has definitely not gone into decline. A popular reason quoted for nations with a majority of nonbelievers scoring high on goodness is that the population there does not ‘wait for God’ to help them — they help themselves, thereby increasing output and efficiency. Here we are not discussing a country like China — with an HDI rank in the 70s — although it is overwhelmingly atheist, because the atheism in China is official policy and not voluntary as in other countries.
What is the broader meaning of ‘goodness’? Psychologists assess personality traits of individuals and studies have been carried out to compare believers and atheists on parameters of integrity and the ability to take moral and ethical decisions. It was presumed that since morality was believed to have predominantly come from religion, the moral intuition of the two groups would differ. M Hauser and P Singer, in their Morality Without Religion, conclude that there is no statistically significant difference between believers and atheists in making such moral judgements.
So then should we still believe that God acts like, say, through the Indian Penal Code that is expected to reduce bad deeds by putting fear in the minds of the perpetrators of evil? Looking at the way things pan out across the world, it does appear that we do not require God (or Satan) to do something good or bad. Bad deeds, especially, are always a result of misguided personal convictions, with God being conveniently put forth as an excuse.
Related Topics
Related News & Articles
It’s a political issue; for four years not much was talked about it and suddenly it has become an issue once again. As a nation, we need to move forward, we n...
Recently posted . 925 views . 5 min read
adhguru: In India, various kinds of gods and especially goddesses have been created. Certain yogis and mystics created particular forms for specific purposes. Som...
Recently posted . 1K views . 9 min read
Millions will gather today, in India and around the world, to offer prayers, worship, and devotional songs glorifying the appearance of the Divine mother, Radha (Ra...
Recently posted . 2K views . 3 min read
Instead of investing huge amounts of money on festivities and idols, religious institutions would do well to spend on philanthropic efforts for people in need.
Recently posted . 922 views . 1 min read
In Hinduism, each day in a week is dedicated to a particular god in the Hindu pantheon. Thursday, which is Brihaspatiwar or Vrihaspativar, is dedicated to Vishnu an...
Recently posted . 2K views . 4 min read
Trending News & Articles
Nanda Vrata is dedicated to Shiva and it is believed that Goddess Sati observed this vrat to get Shiva as her husband. It is observed during Phalgun Shukla Paksha...
Recently posted . 17K views . 3 min read
This question has seeked me ever since I can remember ...from my childhood..in my dreams...in my realisation and my internal assimilation of Lord Krishna as my god....
Recently posted . 9K views . 1 min read
Story of Sharabha and Narasimha
In Hinduism, the ‘trimurti’ (Gods) - Brahma, Vishnu, Mahesh, are...
Recently posted . 7K views . 1 min read
Have any of you realised how beneficial and helpful the lemon is when kept in a transparent glass of water, what it does? Here is the lemon ...
Recently posted . 6K views . 1 min read
More in Spiritual
Uddhava, the apprentice of Krishna, one day expressed his dissatisfaction to Krishna that in-spite of studying all Vedas ,Upnishadas and Sutras, he still was not ...
Recently posted. 1K views . 2 min read
Women should speak up. When they stand and speak up, in future, people will be more careful. They will not use them as objects, as use and throw stuff. In the ent...
Recently posted. 785 views . 4 min read
Wat Pa Maha Chedi Kaew is a Buddhist temple in the Khun Han district of Sisaket province in Thailand.
Recently posted. 863 views . 0 min read
Recently posted . 2K views
Recently posted . 395 views
Recently posted . 3K views
Recently posted . 4K views
Success and wellbeing are things that everyone looks for. Each of us may have individual ideas of what success is and follow different routes to wellbeing, but th...
Recently posted. 1K views . 3 min read
In these religiously divisive times, it's soul-gladdening to remember that Sufis, Muslim mystics, celebrated Holi and Diwali and never thought that the festival...
Recently posted. 1K views . 2 min read