• Home
  • National News
  • Following Franklin, pain spreads to other mutual funds with Vodafone Idea exposure
Following Franklin, pain spreads to other mutual funds with Vodafone Idea exposure
National  
livemint

The highest drop was in UTI Credit Risk Fund which saw a 10.42% fall in Net Asset Value
Franklin Templeton AMC imposed a limit of ₹2 lakh per investor per day into its schemes hit by Vodafone Idea exposure

 

Following a 100% write down by Franklin Templeton Mutual Fund on Thursday of its Vodafone Idea debt holdings, other mutual funds have also seen drops in the value of their holdings. Aditya Birla Sun Life Mutual Fund, Nippon India Mutual Fund and UTI Mutual Fund saw cuts to their debt funds on Friday as valuation agencies marked down Vodafone Idea paper. The highest drop was in UTI Credit Risk Fund which saw a 10.42% fall in Net Asset Value (NAV). The write downs were in response to the Supreme Court’s AGR ruling on 16th January. Vodafone Idea has become liable to pay dues of around ₹50,000 crore by 23rd January.
 
The NAV drops were 30-60% of the actual exposure of schemes to Vodafone Idea, implying that there could be further loss of value if the company actually defaults or is downgraded by ratings agencies. The latter have been slow to change the Vodafone Idea rating below investment grade, preventing mutual funds from creating side pockets. Side pockets or segregated portfolios allow a mutual fund to carve out its exposure to bad paper while allowing investors to redeem units in the rest of the scheme. These side pockets also stop speculators from entering the scheme and benefiting from recovery in the debt at the expense of the original investors.
 
Franklin Templeton AMC imposed a limit of ₹2 lakh per investor per day into its schemes hit by Vodafone Idea exposure. However none of the other AMCs have moved to restrict inflows, leaving them vulnerable to entry by speculators. “Vodafone comes from a pedigreed industrial group and one very large multinational. When you push such a company to the brink by an AGR order, this has no precedence in any risk model. The company won cases in TDSAT and High Court, before the adverse ruling in the Supreme Court," said Amandeep Singh Chopra, Group President and Head Fixed Income at UTI Mutual Fund in an interview to Mint. “The actual amount is 11,000 crore which has been made into 50,000 crores due to penalty and interest. Even the biggest industrial house in the country cannot pay ₹50,000 crore in 3 months," he added.
 
Investors who exited the affected schemes on Friday were hit by the unannounced sharp drops in NAV. However those remaining put run the risk of further write downs. They also run the risk of rising exposure to bad paper in the portfolio, as the schemes in question sell high rated paper to meet redemptions. "Investors in Franklin schemes have already seen the value of Vodafone papers written down completely leaving no further downside from the papers. Assuming they signed up for the credit risk involved and are happy with the overall strategy and the remaining portfolio of the fund house, they can stay put. Those in schemes other than Franklin ones, should evaluate two factors. First, their potential loss from further write downs and second the costs of exit such as exit load and tax. Depending on which factor has higher weightage, they should make a decision," said Amol Joshi of Plan Rupee Financial Services.

 
 


 
 


 
More in National
Average salary at record Rs 28 lakh in IIM Calcutta final placements

439 students bagged 492 offers from 136 firms participating in the placements process. The Consulting sector was the largest recruiter with 31% offers. Marquee Fina...

Recently posted . 8 views

The National Population Register Has No Proper Legal Backing and May B...

In the entire discussion on NPR, NRC and CAA, one important point seems to have been missed out – the legal status of the NPR. Nowhere does the Citizenship Ac...

Recently posted . 10 views

Basic Vs Standard: CBSE Class 10 Mathematics Paper Marking Scheme Expl...

CBSE class 10 mathematics exam is scheduled on March 12. This is the first year when exam will be held for Basic and Standard Mathematics.

Recently posted . 8 views

All medical devices to be treated as ‘drugs’ from April 1: Govt

The central government on Tuesday notified all medical devices as ‘drugs’, effective from April 1, bringing a range of products from instruments to impl...

Recently posted . 23 views

'Men Scaled Walls, Masturbated and Molested Us': Gargi College Student...

Recalling the moment when the mob entered the campus, one of the students, said, 'There were middle-aged men jumping over the fence over the high walls. The f...

Recently posted . 19 views

Supreme Court Upholds Constitutional Validity of SC/ST Amendment Act

A bench headed by Justice Arun Mishra said a preliminary inquiry is not essential before lodging an FIR under the act and the approval of senior police officials is...

Recently posted . 14 views

 
 
 

Prashnavali

Thought of the day

Be proud, but never satisfied.
Anonymous