Latest News

  • Home
  • National
  • View: It is not for soldiers to question why, but it must be asked, how did Pulwama happen?
View: It is not for soldiers to question why, but it must be asked, how did Pulwama happen?
Monday, March 25, 2019 IST
View: It is not for soldiers to question why, but it must be asked, how did Pulwama happen?

In the process, one vital question has been left to blow forlornly in the wind: why and how did Pulwama happen?
 

 
 

Speaking at the 80th raising day of the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), National Security Adviser Ajit Doval said that the nation’s leadership is capable of reacting to any terror attack, and will decide if the retaliation should target terrorists or those who control them. That is very well, but what about preventing another attack? 
 
When a suicide bomber drove a vehicle laden with some 300 kg of explosives into a convoy of CRPF personnel at Pulwama, the result was tragedy. Over 40 security men were killed, several more wounded. The immediate reaction was sorrow, anger and outrage. The attack was claimed by the Pakistan-based Jaish-e-Mohammed (JeM), headed by Masood Azhar. In retaliation, the government sent Indian warplanes into Pakistani territory and bombed targets there. 
 
Theirs not to question why 
 
The response was powerful, justified and recognised as such by most global powers. Pakistan came under immense pressure to release the Indian fighter pilot it had shot down and captured. India won diplomatic support for putting Masood Azhar on the UN’s sanctions list from most countries, save China. 
 
The general reaction in India was one of jubilation at breaking free from Pakistan’s nuclear thrall. Prime Minister Narendra Modi who dared to take the decision to use air power, even if only for a “pre-emptive, non-military” strike, basked in the glow of public approval. But, in the process, one vital question has been left to blow forlornly in the wind: why and how did Pulwama happen? When military men die, the popular response is one of grief and admiration for their heroism. Rarely do ask people whether those deaths were necessary. 
 
Not though the soldier knew/ Someone had blundered./ Theirs not to make reply,/ Theirs not to reason why,/ Theirs but to do and die/ Into the valley of death/ Rode the six hundred. The Charge of the Light Brigade evokes awe of military bravery and sacrifice, but it also deplores blundered loss of life. 
 
The mid-19th century Crimean war, in which a traditional British light cavalry brigade charged a deployment of Russian cannon, providing Alfred Tennyson with the material for his poem, caused so much needless loss of life and treasure that the resultant public outcry led to professionalisation of the British army and the conduct of war.
 
In India, the death of brave soldiers provokes similar awe at their bravery and sacrifice. But the needed follow-through of professionalisation of conduct in matters of war and security just does not happen. 
 
The Pathankot Air Force Station was attacked in January 2016. Six soldiers were killed. India handed over proof to Islamabad of their non-State actors’ involvement in the attack, even invited their people to investigate the crime scene. Deadpan, Pakistani investigators declared that India had stage-managed the attack to malign Pakistan.

 
 

Six months later, an army brigade headquarters at Uri was attacked. It left 19 soldiers dead. India performed its surgical strikes on terror launch pads across the Line of Control and declared vindication. 
 
Two months later, terrorists attacked an army base at Nagrota, killing seven Indian soldiers. Evidently, the surgical strikes were more effective in spawning Bollywood josh than in preventing further attacks. 
 
Someone had blundered
 
After the Pulwama attack and India’s counter-attack, the National Security Adviser is again threatening retaliation for fresh attacks. Could we have some serious thought on how to prevent such attacks, foiling incipient attacks through intelligence that lives up to its name and pre-emptive action? 
 
If we value the lives of our soldiers, we must focus on preventing such attacks, not revelling in our ability to strike back when a fresh attack happens. For that, fresh attacks must be recognised as security failures on the part of the government that cannot be offset by any subsequent show of force. 
 
Nor is this failure at the level of policing and intelligence gathering alone. Essentially, the failure is that of politics, failure to live up to the promise and challenge of democracy. It is now commonplace for an encounter in Kashmir between India’s armed forces and separatist militants to draw a local crowd of protesters, who seek to shield the militants and help them escape. Some of these civilians end up as collateral damage. Every civilian death breeds yet more alienation and yet more militants.
 
One such young man drove a carload of explosives into the CRPF convoy at Pulwama. 
 
For far too long has India sent its security forces to wage war against its own people in Kashmir, the northeast, the tribal plains and jungles of Jharkhand and Chhattisgarh. This strategy has produced alienation and discontent, propelling the conflict forward from one generation to the next. Soldiers have been killed, as well as civilians and rebels. This strategy must be abandoned. 
 
India’s biggest strength is democracy. Democracy must be the means to resolve separatist conflict and rebellion. Brandishing the sword of retribution serves not to deter fresh attacks, but to whip up nationalist frenzy. That is not the way to honour the dead. 
 

 
 
 
 
 

Related Topics

 
 
 

Trending News & Articles

 Article
Here is the full list of 827 porn websites banned by the DoT

While the Uttarakhand High Court has asked to block 857 websites, the Ministry of Electronics and IT (Meity) found 30 portals without any pornographic content. ...

Recently posted . 61K views . 1 min read
 

 Article
Class XII Boys Raped 16-Year-old in Dehradun School After Watching Porn on Phone: Police

The four boys as well as five school officials, including the director and principal, were arrested after the incident. The minors were presented before the Juvenil...

Recently posted . 8K views . 1 min read
 

 Article
Sept 27,2001 Rahul Gandhi and his girl friend Veronique,was arrested in Logan airport in Boston

Rahul was having an Italian passport and was carrying suitcase full of dollars. Some say it was about was it $2 million. Rahul and his girl friend was th...

Recently posted . 7K views . 7 min read
 

 Article
TOP 10 GYM EQUIPMENT BRANDS IN INDIA 2017

True – Tr...

Recently posted . 6K views . 83 min read
 

 
 

More in National

 Article
The Hindu explains: The Fugitive Economic Offenders Bill, 2017

After the Nirav Modi–PNB fraud worth more than ₹12,000 crore, the Union Cabinet has approved the Fugitive Economic Offenders Bill, 2017.

Recently posted. 568 views . 1 min read
 

 Article
Union agriculture minister Radha Mohan Singh caught urinating in public

An undated picture of Union agriculture minister Radha Mohan Singh urinating in broad daylight has put the BJP in a spot as the photo became a web sensation via web...

Recently posted. 789 views . 14 min read
 

 Article
50% Army Soldiers May Retire Within 5 Years of Recruitment Under Proposed Recruitment Model

The enlistment model, called Tour of Duty (ToD), was first proposed in 2020 to lessen officials' deficiency in the Army and tackle developing guard annuity bi...

Recently posted. 332 views . 1 min read
 

 Reviews
Top Schools In Noida Extension Area



Recently posted . 1K views . 52 min read
 

 Reviews
Book Review: ‘Paradise Towers’ by Shweta Bachchan-Nanda



Recently posted . 1K views . 20 min read
 

 Article
21-year-old Ends Life After Girlfriend is Gang-raped in Front of Him; Two Held

The gangrape came to light two days ago when the girl, who is 17 years old, revealed it during the investigation of the suicide of Savan Sai, her boyfriend.

Recently posted. 521 views . 1 min read
 

 Article
It Is Almost 2020 And India Is Still Struggling With These 11 Issues

It’s been 73 years since India gained independence. Have we as a nation achieved as much as we should have in all these years?   ...

Recently posted. 464 views . 3 min read
 

 
 
 

   Prashnavali

  Thought of the Day

If you do what you always did, you will get what you always got.
Anonymous

Be the first one to comment on this story

Close
Post Comment
Shibu Chandran
2 hours ago

Serving political interests in another person's illness is the lowest form of human value. A 70+ y old lady has cancer.

November 28, 2016 05:00 IST
Shibu Chandran
2 hours ago

Serving political interests in another person's illness is the lowest form of human value. A 70+ y old lady has cancer.

November 28, 2016 05:00 IST
Shibu Chandran
2 hours ago

Serving political interests in another person's illness is the lowest form of human value. A 70+ y old lady has cancer.

November 28, 2016 05:00 IST
Shibu Chandran
2 hours ago

Serving political interests in another person's illness is the lowest form of human value. A 70+ y old lady has cancer.

November 28, 2016 05:00 IST


ads
Back To Top