Latest News

  • Home
  • Global
  • Asia's mini Chinas struggle to capitalize on Trump-Xi trade war
Asia's mini Chinas struggle to capitalize on Trump-Xi trade war
14 November 2019 IST

No one nation is able to reproduce the kind of success China enjoyed in transforming its economy.


The US-China trade war reignited the debate over which developing countries in Asia could take over the mantle of the world’s workshop. The front-runners? India and Indonesia.
A report published Tuesday by Bloomberg Economics shows that no one nation is able to reproduce the kind of success China enjoyed in transforming its economy. Instead, a series of mini Chinas are set to develop, with each trying to leverage advantages but hampered by structural problems such as inadequate infrastructure or political instability.
China’s intricate networks of factories, suppliers, logistics services and transportation infrastructure grew up in a different era, underpinned by money and technology from Japan, Taiwan and Hong Kong at a time of scant regard for the environment, workers’ rights or the few government regulations that were enforced. It had a vast, cheap, literate workforce and gained almost unfettered access to global markets for three decades.
With that access now under threat after more than a year of trade friction with the U.S., Bloomberg Economics considered six metrics, from labor to business regulations, across 10 Asian economies, to identify developing economies that could get a greater share of Asia’s manufacturing pie.
“No single economy has the wherewithal to step into China’s shoes,” wrote Chang Shu and Justin Jimenez in the report. “Many have a low-cost advantage. With the exception of India, all lack China’s scale. And all face challenges on other aspects of competitiveness.”
India tops the export-potential ranking thanks to its vast population, even though it still falls notably below Guangdong -- the proxy used for China in the analysis. Second up is Indonesia, followed by much-touted Vietnam.
Part of the problem is reproducing the kind of supply chains, marketing access and existing contacts that have been built up by small and medium-sized manufacturers in China’s industrial cities.
Take Quanzhou Kuisheng Craft Co. for example. The maker of garden and home decorations in Quanzhou, Fujian province, saw U.S. sales slump 30% after Trump’s tariffs, but not enough to consider shifting production abroad. Instead, the company has managed to maintain its total exports by pursuing other strategies such as applying for patents in Europe to expand sales there, said Sales Manager Will Huang.
“Labor is cheaper in Vietnam, but the working culture is very different,” Huang said at a booth in the Canton Fair, the world’s largest trade exposition, held last month in Guangzhou. He said Chinese workers are more skilled and are willing to work overtime to finish orders on schedule. “In Vietnam, people won’t do that.”
Over the years, Huang said he has only heard of two small rival manufacturers in Quanzhou that moved production to Vietnam.
China retains other advantages too, including strong, stable leadership, a large domestic market and relatively good access to capital. Its factories have also spent decades competing against each other, trimming costs, streamlining production and honing the efficiency of transportation.
Chinese manufacturing prices have been declining since July, helped by cheaper energy costs, making it harder still for overseas factories to compete. And stuttering progress toward a trade truce between the U.S. and China may help relieve some of the pressure on Chinese producers.
“Even if the trade war continues, China is still the dominant player, because there is a huge gap between China’s level and other countries,” said Joao Barbosa, a business development manager at V-Trust Inspection Service Co., a Guangzhou-based quality inspection company that also has offices in India and Vietnam. He said lots of manufacturers in China today don’t need third-party quality inspection. “But for the exact same product in Vietnam, they need it.”
India’s efforts to chase China’s production capability began in earnest five years ago with Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s “Make in India” initiative that offered incentives to foreign companies to open factories.
India is close to overtaking China as the world’s most populous country and its working age population is projected to top 1 billion by 2050. But the advantage of a large supply of cheap labor has been offset by other factors, such as inadequate infrastructure, outdated land and labor regulations, and bureaucratic lethargy.
The South Asian nation has made progress, rising 37 spots since 2017 in the World Bank’s ranking for ease of doing business, but it still comes in at 63rd, trailing not only China, but also Rwanda and Kosovo.


“India has poor infrastructure, high transaction cost and old labor laws making it tough for industrialists to set up large factories for mass production of basic textiles such as five-pocket jeans and shirts,” said Premal H Udani, managing director at Kaytee Corp., a 75-year-old company that supplies apparel to customers in the U.S. and Europe from its factory in the southern Indian state of Tamil Nadu. “Local taxes also haunt them,” he said, with refunds getting stuck in a bureaucratic tangle between government ministries.
It’s a similar tale for Indonesia, which came in second in Bloomberg Economics’ analysis, beating India on macroeconomic stability, but dragged down by poor infrastructure. Indonesian President Joko Widodo said in September that his country has failed to lure factories from China because investors remain wary of cumbersome local rules.
When Sharp Corp. sought to relocate production of washing machines to Indonesia from Thailand, it took the Japanese company two years to set up the factory, find local component suppliers, conduct production tests and solve all the administrative issues, said Andry Adi Utomo, a senior general manager of national sales at PT Sharp Electronics Indonesia.
Indonesia last year launched its Online Single Submission system in a bid to make it easier to obtain a business license. It didn’t help much because separate permits are still required from local government, Utomo said in a phone interview. “The same thing exists for taxation,” he said.
Vietnam, often cited as a potential winner from the trade war, shows that even that advantage may be short-lived. The Trump administration slapped tariffs of more than 400% on steel imports from Vietnam and added the country to a watchlist of possible currency manipulators in May.
The Southeast Asian nation came in third in Bloomberg Economics’ rankings, again hobbled by infrastructure. Indeed, money flowing into new plants in Vietnam is straining the country’s roads and docks, with complaints rising about port congestion.
China has seven of the world’s 10 busiest container ports -- including Shanghai at No. 1. Vietnam’s two biggest ports, Ho Chi Minh Seaport and Cai Mep, rank No. 26 and No. 50, according to Bloomberg Intelligence.
But developing economies aren’t the only ones in Asia gaining from the shift in trading patterns. U.S. firms diverted about $21 billion of imports away from China in the first half of 2019, according to the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development.
Taiwan was the biggest beneficiary, getting a $4.2 billion boost in exports to the U.S. during the period, mostly for office machinery and communication equipment. Mexico was second with a $3.5 billion gain, followed by the European Union at $2.7 billion just ahead of Vietnam at $2.6 billion, the UNCTD reported.
More-advanced, higher-cost nations were excluded from the Bloomberg Economics report.
And even as Asia’s developing nations compete to copy China’s manufacturing ascent, new technologies are changing the nature of global production and supply, making it even harder to reproduce China’s success. As the cost of automation falls, robots are allowing consumer-focused industries such as apparel makers to move production closer to their markets to speed up supply times.
“Other countries all have constraints in different ways,” said Barbosa from V-Trust. “There will be many mini-Chinas.”


Related Topics


Trending News & Articles

'Worse than prison': A rare look inside China's detention camps to 'brainwash' Muslims

ALMATY: Hour upon hour, day upon day, Omir Bekali and other detainees in far western China's new indoctrination camps had to disavow the...

Recently posted . 186K views . 1 min read

What The Shape Of Your Belly Button Says About Your Health

If you have payed attention to the belly buttons of people on the beach or the members of your family, you have probably noticed that they have different shapes and...

Recently posted . 8K views . 2 min read

Top 10 Best Gym Equipment Brands in India 2018

Body fitness is one thing that everyone wants to maintain irrespective of age. Going to the gym and doing some great exercise always helps to maintain your body fit...

Recently posted . 3K views . 2 min read

Top 10 Horrifying Acts of Chemical Warfare and Gas Attacks

In this age of terror, there might be nothing more terrifying than the thought of an attack carried out with chemical weapons. We’ve all heard the horrific ...

Recently posted . 3K views . 4 min read


More in Global

McDonald's Employee Attacked. She Fights Back. Video Is Viral

An argument began after the man saw there were no plastic straws next to the condiments, a witness said.

Recently posted. 602 views . 0 min read

Saudi Arabia-led coalition used banned cluster bombs on school attacks in Yemen: HRW

The Saudi-led coalition fighting radicals in Yemen utilized banned bunch bombs as a part of assaults almost two schools this month, Human Rights Watch said. The gua...

Recently posted. 484 views . 12 min read

Ancient Shell Has Revealed Exactly How Much Shorter Days Were 70 Million Years Ago

A chunk of rock that had been buried in the ground for millions of years has become a new clock for understanding Earth's rotation. Analysis of a fossilised Cre...

Recently posted. 954 views . 1 min read

Holoportation .... awesome technology

Recently posted . 780 views

Never judge people by their appearance

Recently posted . 733 views

Leaseweb hosting review

Recently posted . 1K views . 67 min read

The Best 5 Hiking Backpacks in India – Reviews & Buying Guide

Recently posted . 950 views . 140 min read

Sydney young pleads guilty to plotting terrorist assault on ANZAC Day

A Sydney young pleaded guilty on Friday to plotting a terrorist assault on an Australian Veteran's Day function a year ago. The then 16-year-old was ...

Recently posted. 859 views . 7 min read

Why Do Babies Babble?

If babies had a universal trait, it would have to be their babbling. During the earliest months of their lives, babies' interactions with us basically boil do...

Recently posted. 639 views . 2 min read



  Thought of the Day

When you get into a tight place and everything goes against you until it seems that you cannot hold on for a minute longer, never give up then, for that is just the place and time when the tide will turn.
Harriet Beecher Stowe

Be the first one to comment on this story

Post Comment
Shibu Chandran
2 hours ago

Serving political interests in another person's illness is the lowest form of human value. A 70+ y old lady has cancer.

November 28, 2016 05:00 IST
Shibu Chandran
2 hours ago

Serving political interests in another person's illness is the lowest form of human value. A 70+ y old lady has cancer.

November 28, 2016 05:00 IST
Shibu Chandran
2 hours ago

Serving political interests in another person's illness is the lowest form of human value. A 70+ y old lady has cancer.

November 28, 2016 05:00 IST
Shibu Chandran
2 hours ago

Serving political interests in another person's illness is the lowest form of human value. A 70+ y old lady has cancer.

November 28, 2016 05:00 IST

Back To Top