Boss not guilty if employee kills self due to excess workload, rules Supreme Court
Thursday, June 28, 2018 IST
The issue came to fore when a Maharashtra government employee named Kishor Parashar killed himself in August 2017. Parashar was also allegedly forced to work at odd hours and even on holidays.
In a major ruling, the Supreme Court has said that if an employee takes the extreme step of ending his/her life due to heavy workload at the office, his superior cannot be held accused of abetting the suicide. Rejecting an argument put forth by Bombay High Court’s Aurangabad bench that the accused boss or senior officer should be held accused as the situation that he creates for his junior, even if not deliberate, could lead to a situation in which that person takes that extreme step, the apex court said that the superior can not be adjudged a criminal if he assigns a load of work to an employee.
The issue came to fore when a Maharashtra government employee named Kishor Parashar killed himself in August 2017. His wife lodged a police complaint alleging that her husband’s superior officer at the office of the deputy director of education in Aurangabad used to put lot of pressure for which he had to stay in office beyond his duty hours. Apart from this, Parashar was also allegedly forced to work at odd hours and even on holidays. She also alleged that his salary was stopped and the senior officer warned that he would stop his increment.
Aurangabad police had registered the FIR based on Parashar’s wife complaints. Subsequently, the senior officer had filed place at the Aurangabad bench of the Bombay HC for seeking quashing of the FIR.
However, the High Court had on January 23 rejected the plea to quash the FIR. The HC had then observed that there was no direct abetment and the applicants cannot have any intention that the deceased should commit suicide. It had stressed on the fact that even when the accused persons have no such intention, if they create a situation causing mental tension so as to drive the person to commit suicide, they can be said to be instigating the accused to commit suicide.
Unperturbed by the HC ruling, the senior officer approached the top court. Maharashtra government’s standing counsel Nishant Katneswarkar had appealed against the plea in front of a bench comprising Arun Mishra and U U Lalit. The Supreme Court bench had termed the HC’s rationale behind the verdict as untenable and quashed the FIR.
Justice Lalit while pronouncing the judgment said, “It is true that if a situation is created deliberately so as to drive a person to commit suicide, there would be room for attracting Section 306 of the IPC (abetment to suicide). However, the facts on record in the present case are inadequate and insufficient (to reach that conclusion).” The bench quashed the FIR against the superior officer.
Related Topics
Related News & Articles
The agency has also issued an advisory cautioning tourists and visitors not to venture into the sea during the monsoon season.
Recently posted . 639 views . 1 min read
Bengaluru: Despite Infosys denying corporate administration issues in the organization, the fellow benefactor and organizer Chairman NR Narayan Murthy said on Thurs...
Recently posted . 612 views . 31 min read
This benefit is applicable to those who have joined any of the public sector insurance companies (PSICs) on or before June 28, 1995.
Recently posted . 638 views . 1 min read
A senior police official said they are probing the matter and are questioning the call centre employees to ascertain the nature of calls allegedly made by them to v...
Recently posted . 598 views . 1 min read
The initiative is aimed at ensuring that toilets are constructed in every household in Madhya Pradesh.
Recently posted . 846 views . 1 min read
Trending News & Articles
While the Uttarakhand High Court has asked to block 857 websites, the Ministry of Electronics and IT (Meity) found 30 portals without any pornographic content.
...
Recently posted . 64K views . 1 min read
The four boys as well as five school officials, including the director and principal, were arrested after the incident. The minors were presented before the Juvenil...
Recently posted . 9K views . 1 min read
Rahul was having an Italian passport and was carrying suitcase full of dollars. Some say it was about was it $2 million.
Rahul and his girl friend was th...
Recently posted . 9K views . 7 min read
True – Tr...
Recently posted . 8K views . 83 min read
More in National
Navjot Singh Sidhu has been asked to leave The Kapil Sharma Show following his comments on the Pulwama terror attack. He will be replaced by Archana Puran Singh o...
Recently posted. 704 views . 1 min read
PAN is used for a host of services like applying for license, opening a bank account, for investments (like deposits, mutual funds), applying for loans, buying a ...
Recently posted. 959 views . 1 min read
Lenders to Jaypee Infratech Ltd. rejected a resolution plan submitted by Lakshdeep Investments & Finance Pvt Ltd., the stressed real estate firm said in a stock...
Recently posted. 613 views . 2 min read
Recently posted . 1K views
Recently posted . 1K views
Recently posted . 2K views
Recently posted . 2K views
Recently posted . 3K views . 35 min read
Recently posted . 3K views . 87 min read
Taking exception to what it said was a “communal” move, the JNUSU, said, “This grotesque propaganda of Islamophobia in the name of academic cour...
Recently posted. 592 views . 1 min read
The merger proposal was approved by the board of Jet Airways in September 2015 and was later cleared by the airline's shareholders in April 2016.
Recently posted. 658 views . 1 min read