Opinion | The rule of law must prevail for everyone
National  
livemint

Whether the charges levelled against P. Chidambaram are true or not is for the judiciary to determine, but the circumstances of his arrest suggest an unseemly haste on the CBI’s part

 

Former finance minister and Congress leader P. Chidambaram was taken into custody by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) in what’s being billed as an “INX Media scam" in a swoop on his residence on Wednesday night. The arrest reflects India’s battle against corruption and the ruling party’s poll promise to that effect. Since Chidambaram is a senior member of the opposition, it was inevitable that the action would attract allegations of a “political vendetta" from his party, and so it has been. On his part, the former finance minister has denied any wrongdoing. It is important that the law takes its own course and justice prevails.
 
Whether the Congress leader has violated any law is for the courts to judge. The CBI has alleged that in 2007, when he was finance minister, he used his position to ensure that INX Media got the Foreign Investment Promotion Board’s approval for an overseas investment of ₹305 crore, which involved irregularities—allegedly in lieu of money routed to a consulting firm that his son Karti Chidambaram had a stake in. Both of them have called these charges false. The CBI is keen to press ahead with its prosecution. Whatever the outcome, what has come to concern observers schooled in law is the weight of force being used in this case. The merits of the case against him apart, the dramatic arrest does raise concerns about whether he was accorded a benefit that every citizen must get: The right to stay out of prison until proven guilty. To be sure, it was after the Delhi high court withdrew his anticipatory bail granted last July that law enforcers swung into action, but how justice delivery would have been constrained by his staying free still remains unclear. Suspicions of his conduct were fanned by the fact that he was “missing" for 27 hours, and that too, in the glare of television coverage. On Tuesday, raiding teams had converged on his house, and, when he wasn’t found, a notice was pasted on one of the walls directing him to appear before the investigating agency within two hours. Even a “lookout" notice was issued so that he didn’t flee the country. But then, he did indeed show up for a press conference at his party headquarters, before returning home, from where he was finally picked up. The charges he faces are not heinous, nor has he been declared an absconder. So long as he cooperates with the authorities, adheres to all legal procedures, and does nothing that could threaten the probe and judicial process, harsh treatment is hard to justify.
 
Some have argued that in high-profile cases, suspects should not get anticipatory bail. But why should the well-known be treated differently? If another standard is applied to famous people, then it would go against the canon of equality under the law. It is true that cases of political corruption evoke much public anger, but the law is still the same for all. It is also true that guilt rarely gets proven in complex cases. In the 2G telecom spectrum case, for instance, while the odd manner in which a first-come-first-served sales window was arbitrarily opened raised doubts over the integrity of the process, no corruption charges were proven against former telecom minister A. Raja. He was acquitted by the Supreme Court, but, ironically, not before spending time in jail. No matter how scandalous people may think a politician’s conduct is, the rule of law must prevail. So too for everybody, famous or not.

 
 


 
 


 
More in National
Interest on delayed GST payment will now be calculated on net tax liab...

• There have been cases where GST assessees have paid taxes after due date but did not pay the interest due on account of delayed...

Recently posted . 10 views

D-Mart’s Radhakishan Damani now 2nd richest Indian after RIL’s Mukesh ...

Avenue Supermart founder Radhakishan Damani is now the second richest Indian after leaving behind heavyweight names such as philanthropist Shiv Nadar, banker Uday K...

Recently posted . 7 views

Flying out from Terminal 3 of Delhi airport? Get bags picked from home

NEW DELHI: The passengers flying out of Delhi now have the option of getting their luggage transported from their place of stay to the airport for ...

Recently posted . 7 views

When Ratan Tata fell in love and ‘almost got married'

He talks at length, in what appears to be a three-part story, about his life growing up, his parents' divorce and how his grandmother raised him and his brother...

Recently posted . 7 views

Bend It Like... This Kerala 10-Year-Old. Watch His "Near Impossible" G...

In the video, the boy is seen curving the ball directly into the net out of the reach of the opponent's team goalkeeper.

Recently posted . 6 views

 
 
 

Prashnavali

Thought of the day

"Obstacles are those frightful things you see when you take your eyes off your goal."
Henry Ford